Opinion
Less work for ethics committees as consensus replaced controversies
LETTER — Posted Feb. 25, 2008
Regarding: "Willing, but waiting: Hospital ethics committees" (Article, Jan. 28): Ethics committees have lost their bearings for two reasons.
First, the controversial ethical issues that they were formed to address -- controversies over the ethical appropriateness of withholding or withdrawing various medical treatments under various circumstances -- largely have been resolved. Through input from legal, bioethical and religious leaders, we have reached a societal consensus on most of the matters that were deeply divisive 20 years ago.
Today, cases like those of Karen Quinlan or Nancy Cruzan would not need to go to ethics committees. Even the case of Terri Schiavo, for all the legal maneuvering, ultimately reinforced the prevailing consensus. After all was said and done, even Congress and the president couldn't stop the removal of Schiavo's feeding tube.
A second reason why ethics committees are less active than they used to be is that most hospitals now have palliative care services. These specialists do a lot of the work that ethics committees once did. They help patients and families come to decisions about what to withhold or withdraw.
Does this mean that there is nothing left for ethics committees to do? Probably not. But ethics committees need to understand better the flashpoints of disagreement that arise in hospitals today with regard to end-of-life decision-making.
Those disagreements likely are quite different now than they used to be. But they are unlikely to have gone away entirely.
John Lantos, MD, Kansas City, Mo.
Editor's note: Dr. Lantos is the John B. Francis Chair in Bioethics at the Center for Practical Bioethics, Kansas City, Mo.
Note: This item originally appeared at http://www.ama-assn.org/amednews/2008/02/25/edlt0225.htm.












