Opinion
Insurers are using an overly broad definition of "preexisting condition"
LETTER — Posted March 10, 2008
Regarding "California appeals court rules against insurer's rescission practices" (Article, Feb. 11): Recent decisions by California's 2nd and 4th District Courts of Appeal reported in AMNews have given me new hope that an abusive insurance practice finally will be revisited. The decisions address the rescinding of a health insurance policy after a claim is made by retrospectively reviewing the insured's application and alleging fraud.
The more common abusive practice to which I am referring is the excluding of insurance coverage for a disease after a claim is made by retrospectively reviewing the insured's medical records and alleging that the disease was preexisting.
I recall one particularly egregious example of an insured woman with colon cancer who was denied coverage because, six months earlier, while her husband was unemployed and at home, her family physician had empirically and successfully treated her with an antacid for an "upset stomach."
As is most often the case, she paid what she was able to afford, and the bulk of her cancer treatment costs were borne by her providers.
This typical policy allowed the insurer to unilaterally and retrospectively decree that the patient and/or her doctor knew, or should have known, that the disease existed before the effective date of the policy. This definition of a "preexisting condition" is far too broad.
We are told these days that each chargeable patient encounter requires a CPT procedure code to identify what was done and an ICD diagnosis code to identify why it was done. That diagnosis can be made only by a physician contemporaneously, and should not be subject to retrospective revision by anyone, let alone a corporation unlicensed to practice medicine.
Joseph N. Michelotti, MD, Elgin, Ill.
Note: This item originally appeared at http://www.ama-assn.org/amednews/2008/03/10/edlt0310.htm.












