Profession
Ariz. appeals court voids expert witness requirements
NEWS IN BRIEF — Posted Aug. 11, 2008
Arizona doctors fear that a recent appeals court ruling could open the door to frivolous lawsuits and reverse improvements in the medical liability environment.
The Arizona Court of Appeals in June unanimously struck down as unconstitutional a statute regulating the qualifications of expert witnesses in medical liability cases. The 2005 law required physicians testifying as expert witnesses to be actively practicing or teaching in the same specialty as the defendant.
At least 25 states have passed similar laws, according to American Medical Association data.
But judges concluded that the Arizona statute violated the separation of powers between the Legislature and the judiciary. Judges said the law imposed stricter limits on expert witnesses than existing court regulations. An appeal to the state Supreme Court is expected.
"It's just common sense that with medicine being as specialized as it is now, expert witnesses at least practice in the same area that is under litigation," said David Landrith, vice president of policy and political affairs for the Arizona Medical Assn. The organization plans to file a friend-of-the-court brief in the high court.
Landrith said that since it passed, the statute has contributed to a 25% drop in medical liability claims.
Note: This item originally appeared at http://www.ama-assn.org/amednews/2008/08/11/prbf0811.htm.












