Opinion
Medical home designation carries threat of more scut work
LETTER — Posted Dec. 22, 2008
Regarding "AMA meeting: Delegates back medical home, want pay issues resolved" (Article, Dec. 1): Paying primary care doctors more to enlist as medical home doctors has potentially negative consequences for them.
Already these physicians are plagued with an excess of paperwork that comes from many quarters: specialists, nurses, hospitals and many, many others.
The usual term for this work is scut work, a pejorative term doctors learn in their residencies to describe the mind-numbing paperwork that no one else wants to do. Most of this work in independent practice falls on the primary care doctor's shoulders.
The point is that when these doctors become formally designated as medical home supervisors, every other member of the health team who is looking for an excuse to shun paperwork will quickly pass it off to the primary care doctors, especially when it is clear that they are getting paid extra for being designated as medical home directors.
Any increased income primary care doctors receive will not be worth the added stress and drudgery attached to it. Yes, pay them more but do not increase the amount of the mind-numbing paperwork they already deal with.
Under the current payment system for primary care doctors, the best way for them to survive is to simply limit the number of patients they see. It is the only way for them to control the drudgery and threat of burnout that they face.
Of course, this will worsen the primary care access problem which already exists and hasten the deployment of nurse practitioners and physician assistants to provide some primary care services, something that many doctors oppose. But, there are not enough physicians around to do the job and there are no prospects of getting more into the work force soon.
If it is true that necessity is the mother of invention, then it is only a matter of time before midlevel providers have more high-profile roles in the health system.
Edward J. Volpintesta, MD, Bethel, Conn.
Note: This item originally appeared at http://www.ama-assn.org/amednews/2008/12/22/edlt1222.htm.












