Business
Goodwill hunting: What's your practice worth?
■ The sales value of a practice is set mainly by intangible assets such as patient mix, physician reputation and number of interested buyers. For many practices, those assets aren't worth what they used to be.
By Karen Caffarini — Posted Sept. 15, 2008
- WITH THIS STORY:
- » When to have your practice valued
- » How goodwill is determined
- » Boosting your goodwill value
Steven Arnold, MD, believes he has built up goodwill valued by the patients he's cared for during his nearly two decades as a family physician in Milo, a rural town of 2,000 near Maine's geographical center.
What Dr. Arnold hasn't been able to do is build up the kind of goodwill that makes his practice valuable enough for anyone else to buy.
A practice's goodwill consists of intangible assets, including patient base, accounts receivable, reputation, location, size, specialty and payer mix. While a building and equipment are tangible assets that fetch a market rate as set by federal and state law, goodwill is the variable that makes or breaks a practice's salable value.
"People are still paying a premium to join the right practice. If you're in the middle of nowhere with no real barrier to entry, no one is inclined to pay a premium for your practice. They can just set up their own practice and compete with you," says Sandra McGraw, JD, CEO of The Health Care Group Inc., a physician advisory firm in Plymouth Meeting, Pa. "But if you want to join an ophthalmologist practice in Manhattan, generally you will be willing to pay goodwill. It would be difficult financially to start on your own."
Unfortunately for Dr. Arnold, a small practice in rural Maine with 60% of its patient base on Medicare or Medicaid doesn't have the payer mix buyers are seeking. On Nov. 1, Dr. Arnold is shutting down the practice he acquired for $125,000 in 1989 -- $25,000 of it for goodwill -- and taking an employed position with a federally qualified health center 15 miles away in Dover-Foxcroft.
"People aren't buying practices here -- they're just absorbing them. Apparently they don't have to pay for them," Dr. Arnold says.
He discovered three years ago, while trying to form a partnership, that his practice could command no goodwill, making it virtually worthless. Dr. Arnold says that with reimbursement rates only getting worse, he has to leave or go bankrupt.
He didn't even try to sell his practice. "It has no value. Anyone who would buy my practice would be bankrupt in six months. I don't want to stick anyone." Dr. Arnold donated his 3,500-square-foot building, appraised at $282,000 several years ago, to the town of Milo.
Today, potential purchasers are more tight-fisted and particular concerning goodwill payouts, pointing to reduced reimbursements from managed care plans, lack of patient loyalty and the fact that some earlier buyers overpaid and got stung, advisers say.
David Marcinko, CEO of Medical Business Advisors in Atlanta, says that in the late 1990s he was seeing internal medicine and primary care practices sell for up to five times their gross annual revenue, boosted mainly by goodwill. Today these practices are more likely to receive one to two times their gross annual revenue.
Maximizing your goodwill
Goodwill matters not only when a practice is for sale, but also when a group is setting a formula for a new physician to buy a partnership or for a retired physician to cash out of one. Goodwill also matters when a value is being set on the practice during a legal proceeding, such as divorce or a liability case. Experts say goodwill value needs to be determined only when a practice anticipates an alteration in its ownership structure. With appraisals costing up to $30,000, simple curiosity likely isn't enough reason to seek out a number.
Chances of getting a more favorable goodwill value will be improved if physicians have good records of accounts receivable and capital purchases and maintain a profitable practice, advisers say.
"At the end of the day, what matters is that you have a well-functioning, good business," McGraw says.
Setting goodwill isn't just about the cash value of your practice. It also could affect your taxes, says Keith Kamperschroer of Kolb and Co. health care consultants in Milwaukee.
"If the buyer adds a ... sign-on bonus, that puts the doctor in the highest tax bracket, 35%. But if you argue that the bonus is for the personal goodwill of a doctor, which is an intangible asset, it is considered a capital asset and taxed at 15%," Kamperschroer says. However, he says the IRS can, and has, stepped in if it deems the amount of goodwill was set unreasonably high in comparison with similar practices.
As in real estate, amenities and location affect a practice's goodwill value. The more varied the payer mix, the better, experts say. That way, a practice can prove it is not reliant on a dominant payer that could negatively affect the practice by lowering reimbursements or splitting from the practice. The definition of one dominant payer includes self-paying patients, which is why, experts say, a cash-based practice might not have a high goodwill level.
In large metro areas, fast-growing locations, or areas where health systems are actively acquiring practices, physician groups have a better shot at fetching some level of goodwill, experts say.
Right place at the right time
The Milauskas Eye Institute in Palm Springs, Calif., is one practice that hit the trifecta: right practice, right specialty and right place. So it was able to maximize its goodwill value assessment.
Tim Milauskas, administrator of Milauskas Eye Institute, says its goodwill value came in higher than expected. In fact, he says, the practice's value is higher today than it was in the 1990s, when it was sold to a practice management group. Milauskas did not reveal numbers.
When the practice management company folded, the founder bought back the practice at a lower cost. It has since grown to 12 ophthalmologists and optometrists, compared with the two or three ophthalmologists in most other practices in the area. Milauskas says the practice accepts most major insurance plans but no longer contracts with HMOs.
The practice had other aspects that made it ripe for receiving goodwill, experts say. It is in Southern California, a prime location; it represents a specialty in demand; it is the dominant practice in its specialty; it's consistently grown through the years; and it's made wise decisions regarding payers.
"Goodwill in this day and age is a very amorphous thing," Milauskas says.
By contrast, rural Maine, where Dr. Arnold is, is not an ideal place to sell a practice, according to Andrew MacLean, general counsel for Maine Medical Assn.
"I would be fairly skeptical that you would find much in the way of goodwill here. Hospitals continue to buy primary care and specialty care practices, but they aren't paying goodwill." MacLean says.












