Government
Medicare costs for end-of-life care higher for minority patients
■ Misallocation of care could affect patient decisions in the final six months, a new study suggests.
By Chris Silva — Posted March 27, 2009
Despite receiving fewer medical services and spending less on health care throughout most of their lives, ethnic minorities on average have higher costs in their last six months of life than do white patients, a new study found.
Although disease death rates for elderly blacks and Hispanics are similar to those for whites, Medicare costs involved in end-of-life care for minority patients are significantly higher, according to a report by researchers from Boston University School of Medicine, Lown Cardiovascular Research Foundation in Brookline, Mass., and the Dept. of Bioethics at the National Institutes of Health. The study of nearly 160,000 Medicare patients was published in the March 9 Archives of Internal Medicine.
Average Medicare costs for white patients in the last six months of life were just more than $20,000. But that figure rises to $26,704 for blacks and to $31,702 for Hispanics.
Blacks and Hispanics are significantly more likely than whites to be admitted to an intensive care unit in the final six months of life. A larger proportion of minorities also receive more intensive and invasive procedures, such as resuscitation and cardiac conversion, mechanical ventilation, and gastrostomy for nutrition. Whites, however, are more likely to receive inpatient cancer chemotherapy. Whites also are more likely to use hospice care, which accounts for some reduction in costs.
Part of the cost discrepancy can be associated with geography, with many minorities living in areas with higher rates of hospital use, the authors said. But other factors play into why nonwhites receive more expensive -- but not necessarily life-enhancing -- care at the end.
Patient preferences are one factor. Some studies have found that ethnic minorities are more reluctant than whites to have do-not-resuscitate orders and more likely to request life-sustaining measures in their final months.
But the researchers posited that general misallocation of health care resources also could have a significant impact. "Are health care resources for nonwhites misallocated over a lifetime, with racial and ethnic minorities receiving fewer life-extending and life-enhancing interventions than whites throughout their lives but more at the end, when there is less opportunity to improve the quantity and quality of life?" the authors asked.
According to research compiled by the Alliance for Health Reform, a health care resource organization based in Washington, D.C., about one-third of Americans identify themselves as racial or ethnic minorities. That figure is expected to climb to more than 50% by 2042.












